Opinion: Guards at opening

Subject: Guards at opening

Code:
IRC Section R316

Submitted By: AMBO Uniformity Committee

Approved By: Thomas R. Joachim, State Building Official

Issue Date: December 2003

Question: A builder is constructing a new home with a loft overlooking a living room 9 feet below. The builder wants to place a 6 square foot opening in the loft wall overlooking the living room so that the homeowner will have a view of the room below. The opening will start one foot above the floor and be two feet wide. Does this opening require a guard? A few feet from this opening is a window that has an opening 2 feet wide by 3 feet high and has a sill one-foot above the floor. Does this window require a guard? The window has no screen. If the window does not require a guard, how does the threat of falling through this opening differ from the potential of falling from the interior opening?

Answer: This would be an opening not a window. A guard would be required.

Committee comments: A guard would be required for an opening in a wall more than 30” above floor or grade below. A guard would not be required at a window. Guards at windows have been proposed at numerous national code hearings and have consistently been disapproved.

Subject:	Guards at opening
Code:	IRC Section R316
Submitted By:	AMBO Uniformity Committee
Approved By:	Thomas R. Joachim, State Building Official
Issue Date:	December 2003
Question:	A builder is constructing a new home with a loft overlooking a living room 9 feet below. The builder wants to place a 6 square foot opening in the loft wall overlooking the living room so that the homeowner will have a view of the room below. The opening will start one foot above the floor and be two feet wide. Does this opening require a guard? A few feet from this opening is a window that has an opening 2 feet wide by 3 feet high and has a sill one-foot above the floor. Does this window require a guard? The window has no screen. If the window does not require a guard, how does the threat of falling through this opening differ from the potential of falling from the interior opening?
Answer:	This would be an opening not a window. A guard would be required.
Committee comments:	A guard would be required for an opening in a wall more than 30” above floor or grade below. A guard would not be required at a window. Guards at windows have been proposed at numerous national code hearings and have consistently been disapproved.